Barbiere's Italian Inn: An Authentic Slice of Italy in Milwaukee

This is a very quaint pizza spot. It’s quiet and cozy. The wait staff was very friendly and kind. Very sweet ladies!!! We had the pizza with cheese, sausage and pepperoni. I think I was expecting a more robust pizza, but it was cool. We also had a salad which only consisted of iceberg lettuce and a few grape tomatoes. We also ordered the lasagna. I absolutely loved the butter bread. It was incredibly crunchy with no garlic salt or spread which was a plus for me. Please get the lemonade! Very refreshing!!! Overall, we enjoyed our visit! If you want a quiet pizza place to just chill, this is the spot for you!

This place was one of the first places i ate when i moved to the area. I was taken aback with it's no frills but 100% comfortable atmosphere. Low lights, stable and simple furniture, and classy but simple decor. The waitstaff proved to be equally wonderful, making you feel like a valued customer instantly with a warm smile. Food. No one will top the feeling i got from that first bite of buttery, garlic infused bread. Crisp and tender and dripping. The lasagna is some of the richest food money can buy, and here at Barbiere's you will receive top level value. I want this restaurant to last forever.

Excellent Food, generous portions, great prices. Service is also amazing!! Owner is an EXTREMELY GENEROUS STAND UP GUY WHO OFFERED FREE PIZZA AND DRINKS TO FAMILIES AFFECTED BY THE GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN. BLESS HIM !!!

Enjoyed dinner here for the first time on Friday 2/10/2023, ordered a small Caesar salad (delicious and huge), ordered a small pizza w/sausage, pepperoni, and onion, it was so delicious, the crust was nice and flakey w/a good crunch. MaryJo was the bartender and also our server, she was such a wonderful lady, enjoyed having her take care of me and my friend (she ordered the small Caesar salad and lunch size lasagna (nice portion). Between the service and the food, I will be going back to try other items on their menu. I had interaction with two other lady servers and they both were a delight, very friendly and helpful same at the bartender Mary Jo.

Who would have guessed this hidden gem would be so good. Excellent pizza with crisp crust and tasty cheese. Best yet was the garlic bread which was one of a kind and beyond good. Price was reasonable and service was good. A must visit.

Long time, old school neighborhood Italian restaurant - carry out and dining room. I’ve been coming here for 24 + years. Nothing fancy but Quality food, fair prices, great service. Unique garlic bread is crispy, tasty and buttery. The red sauce — especially the sauce with meat and mushrooms— is outstanding. Good portions, good value. Was there last night with group of 5 and a couple of things were just a bit off (garlic bread was not as garlicky as typical and the chicken in my cacciatore was fully cooked but not as tender / fall off the bone as usual). I called the restaurant today to let them know and was pleasantly surprised that the owner- steve- was there and he was apologetic and said he would see what happened and make sure it doesn’t happen again. What more can you ask for. I’ll be back soon for the bread, sauce and good vibe.

Our go to place for a few favorites. Wonderful pizza, especially their crust. Thick and drippy garlic bread with meat sauce and a salad. Must try their homemade ranch dressing. And the meatball snack is amazing too! Ask for a "half bake" order and you can finish baking at home.

The best garlic bread I've ever had in my whole life and I'm originally from Colorado Springs and we had a place back home called Giuseppe's the depot and they always had the best garlic bread well these two places could go neck and neck as far as food quality service atmosphere both TOP notch!!!